Annie Lennox slams plans for Aberdeen civic square

Business boss hits out over Union Terrace Gardens scheme

By David Ewen chief reporter

Published: 09/02/2010

A PROPOSAL to give Aberdeen a new heart has been savaged in separate attacks by singer Annie Lennox and a business leader.

Ms Lennox and Balmoral Group boss Jim Milne slated plans to create a civic square above Union Terrace Gardens in Aberdeen.

Mr Milne claimed the business community felt “pressurised” into supporting the vision, put forward by fellow energy tycoon Sir Ian Wood.

However, the allegation was rejected as “nonsense” by the team leading the project – which also said it was a mistake to suggest Aberdeen would lose its greenery.

Ms Lennox, 55, said she feared the Aberdeen gardens would be replaced by “concrete”.

She said: “Aberdeen was my home town. I was born there and lived in the city until I was 17.

“For me, Union Terrace Gardens was, and still is, the green, historical heart of the city.”

Mr Milne stressed he didn’t want to appear “anti-Ian” but said: “I personally know many individuals, especially within the business sector, feel pressurised into supporting the project by their peers.”

Sir Ian has offered £50 million towards the £140m project to raise Aberdeen’s Victorian park to street level.

It would cover over the gardens, railway line and Denburn dual-carriageway.

The scheme – which is out for public consultation – is being led by development body Aberdeen City and Shire Economic Future.

Chairman Tom Smith said Ms Lennox appeared to have made her comments based on a “wholly inaccurate description” of the project, which would have as much room for greenery as the gardens.

Peacock Visual Arts, has planning permission for a £13m contemporary arts centre to be built in the gardens.

dewen@ajl.co.uk

Reader's Comments

Given she doesn't live in the city and hasn't done so for almost 40 years, how can her voice be counted at all?!
Tracy C
Report this comment

Tracy, if the city square project is intended to attract national and international visitors and investment - as Sir Ian Wood and Acsef maintain is the case - then the opinions of folk outwith Aberdeen are highly relevant to the development. If they agree it's an attractive idea that will attract their custom (either as tourists or business) then all good. But if they see the city square as a destructive force and a return to the 1960s and 1970s visions of town planning that would put them off Aberdeen, don't you think that ought to be of interest when so much money is at stake? Wouldn't it be irresponsible to invest in a project that actively discourages tourism and investment?
Richard Fraser
Report this comment

Annie Lennox couldn't get out of Aberdeen quick enough in the early 70's. Looking at Union Terrace Gardens through a pair of nostalgic rose tinted glasses doesn't help either. As a mother I'll bet she wouldn't let her kids anywhere near them today. As far as planning in the 60's and 70's is concerned did we not have a Provost going by the name of Robbie Lennox who would have been an integral part of that? I seem to remember he was Annie's uncle. She should stick to saving sub-saharan Africa and leave all us with commitment to Aberdeen to get a modern 21st century city that we can be proud of. I'm sure we have learned the lessons of the 60's and 70's.
Sandy Milne
Report this comment

I dont see why Annie Lennox is giving us her opinion. Someone who has pretty much slated Aberdeen since the day she 'escaped' from it. What now she cares? Beacause there will be less grass???
Andrew Mitchell
Report this comment

I agree totally with the fact that Annie Lennox is in no position to comment on anything to do with Aberdeen! As stated above, she couldn't wait to get out of here and hasn't looked back since. Does anyone really think she'd ever come back to live in Aberdeen? I appreciate that the designs are to attract outside interest, and I'm more than sure that the current proposals will. However i'm sure that most people will be in agreement with me that I don't really care what an EX-Aberdonian thinks about it. If she so concerned, why doesn't she put up some of her fortune and proposals for it??
kevin mackie
Report this comment

Annie Lennox is perfectly entitled to comment on anything she wants to comment on, just as everybody is here. If she feels strongly enough about the gardens then what's wrong with that? She is merely saying what many in the city think. By the same token, the consultation run by ACSEF has been extended to the shire. So why should someone born in Peterhead have any more say over the gardens than Annie Lennox whose father was provost of Aberdeen? Why should Willie Miller from the Glasgow area not say what he wants? I think the City square project is appalling but I don't want to stop anyone from disagreeing with me.
mike shepherd
Report this comment

What Annie Lennox done for this city, nothing!
Bob Christie
Report this comment

I am so glad that Annie Lennox has spoken out for Union Terrace Gardens. Good on you Annie. Many of us in the city do not want the Gardens to be touched, yet we get portrayed unfairly as the minority view, when it is clear we are not. Now we have a fellow Aberdonian who can give us all a public face. Annie, i'm proud of you.
mike shepherd
Report this comment

"She should stick to saving sub-saharan Africa and leave all us with commitment to Aberdeen to get a modern 21st century city that we can be proud of. I'm sure we have learned the lessons of the 60's and 70's." Ah good someone who knows what modern 21st century city looks like! Sandy Milne is obviously an expert in such matters - perhaps he / she could explain just exactly what does a 21st century city consist of? Actually, taking up the 60s 70s point Ascef's plans look EXACTLY like the vision of 'modern city centres' as proposed in the 60's and 70's. How very retrograde.
Mike Miller
Report this comment

I would just like to say to all the comments about Annie Lennox's "right to comment" what she actually wrote in her blog WAS: The Eurythmics star added: “I’ve been based in London since 1971, so I guess that kind of counts my voice out – but to the citizens of Aberdeen I would say this. “Aberdeen is your home town. Are you going to sit back and do nothing while its beautiful historic centre gets ripped out and concreted over? It’s down to you to stop this happening.” She fully aknowledges her position on this. How many of you want a concrete jungle? I live in one now (livingston) and let me tell you there is absolutely NOTHING Civic or even Civilised about it. Get off your high horses about the fact that she doesn't live in the City anymore and actually think about what this would mean to your City. Also just to add... it's not as if she ever says she's not from Aberdeen, give the woman a break with stuff like this going on it's little wonder she left! Must we always be so quick to judge people so negatively just because they have money and fame. You should be thanking your lucky stars your not Jordans home town!
Morna Bishop
Report this comment

The Evening Express is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.
Click here to read the digital edition.
Follow us on Facebook. Click like
Follow us on Twitter